Free quote checker
Is this car repair estimate fair?
Before you approve a car repair, check whether the estimate tells you enough to decide. Answer a few questions and get the gaps, questions and warning signs specific to your quote.
Before you spend the money, make the decision with confidence.
No sign-up. Your answers stay in your browser.
What a good car repair estimate includes
- A clear description of the problem and how it was diagnosed — a test result, a code reading backed by inspection, or a part you can see.
- Separate lines for parts and labor, with the part type (new, remanufactured, used or aftermarket) and the labor hours.
- Shop fees, taxes and disposal charges listed, not buried in a total.
- Warranty terms for both parts and labor.
Common reasons car repair quotes differ
- Different part types: a remanufactured part and a new dealer part can be priced very differently for the same job.
- Different diagnoses: one shop may replace a whole assembly where another repairs a single component.
- Bundled extras: fluid flushes, filters and "while we're in there" items added to the main repair.
Frequently asked questions
Should I get a second opinion on a car repair?
For large or unexpected repairs, a second opinion can be worth the time. Make sure the second shop is quoting the same diagnosis and part type, or the prices won't be comparable.
Can a shop charge more than the estimate?
Rules vary by state. Some states require shops to get your approval before going over a written estimate. Ask the shop to call you before doing any extra work, and check your state's consumer protection office for the exact rules.
Is it okay to ask to see the old part?
Generally, yes — asking to see replaced parts is a reasonable request. Some parts may need to go back to the supplier (for example, core parts returned for credit), so ask before the work starts.
More quote guides
Have another problem? Solve it with Money Problem Solver.
Car, home, scams, money, bills and purchases — understand it before you pay.
Start a problemIndependent education only. Not a mechanic, contractor, attorney or financial adviser. What we do and don't do.